I believe Obsidian Sync will always have faster specific support, and probably always work faster than more generic solutions. 23. [deleted] • 2 yr. SyncThing and Obsidian work well together! I've done syncthing with Dropbox. stignore files and see how it works for each device, and maybe run test cases, but it’s pretty good and works. Aaravchen. Create a new Obsidian vault (if not already created) on the first computer. If you can afford it, Obsidian Sync is well worth it for the privacy, versioning, granular control of what gets synced, and seamless syncing across any combination of supported platforms, including iOS, Mac, Windows, Android, and Linux. Optionally starts on login, so. Go through the available options and ensure they match the settings for the folder on your PC. Click any of the boxes to explore the topics. This is likely not an Obsidian problem, it's something else. so every time you want to use it on your phone you have to sync manually with nextcloud. Go to the location of your obsidian vault. I've tried the git version (good solution between PCs but not for Android as there is not git support there). First things first: Obsidian Sync vs. These are the five methods currently believed to work for syncing between devices if you’ll be including an iPhone and/or iPad: • iCloud (NOTE: iCloud on Windows is known to cause file duplication issues as well as data corruption and loss, and the Obsidian devs and community strongly recommend that you avoid this combination. For obsidian sync, as far as I know it will only sync when obsidian is running (Google drive, one drive, syncthing, etc. 13. The obsidian Git plugin can be configured to automatically pull the most recent files when starting Obsidian. trying to use syncthing with obsidian. Or you can use any other tools like a notebook or a diary. Seems to be working well. You’ll need to tinker around with the . These are currently the methods believed to work for syncing if you want to include an iPhone and/or iPad: • iCloud (Not recommended if you’re also syncing a Windows device) • Obsidian Sync. Obsidian can be best described as a modular note-taking app and text editor based on an extensible plugin architecture. So when I open obsidian tasker runs the task to sync obsidian and even if obsidian is open it will load on the fly anything added, I just have a 5 second delay so that the app can open normally. 99 - Evernote Personal $10 - Notion $6. I believe Obsidian Sync will always have faster specific support, and probably always work faster than more generic solutions. Check out my comparison: Obsidian vs. git commit -m "date" git push. The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives. 3. I just got SyncThing set up and it works great! However, when I use it on my desktop it will create repeated files with the following name: [name-of-note]. ”. So, I was requesting more control over this auto-merge. Worth noting - there are a lot of solutions out there for Android as well but there's a bit more flexibility there due to the nature of Android. The key is to use only one node to do the syncing with Dropbox (OneDrive). A clear answer, thank you very much. This works but is far from comfortable and missing a certain WAF ;) Is there another way? Like for example "share" photos to Möbius? 5. So what you add in your computer will be synced and offline in your phone. obsidian-releases - Community plugins list, theme list, and releases of Obsidian. . Here's what's possible in an app, which is not a Mind Map, that supports linked information. You can click or tap on your shared folder to "unfold" it and see its details and syncing status. If it fails to. And it has many iseful plugins. This might be the reason obsidian sync is always flawless, because of course it can handle it's own file reservations better than a 3rd party sync solution. OneDrive is primarily a file repository that can be used to sync Obsidian vault by the more adventurous user. ) • Official Obsidian SyncObsidian sync is $8/month (see below for free alternatives) Obsidian Publish is $16/month;. Open, trustworthy and decentralized file synchronization. A backup is a separate copy of your data so if something happens to your working files, you can restore them. The desktop version of the app is similar to Obsidian in that backlinks, linked mentions, etc exist. * Release the wrapper more frequently to identify and fix bugs caused by changes in the syncthing submodule. I will say, I paid for Obsidian Sync and it is worth it for me. Yeah, syncthing can work with Nextcloud. Features Visual conflict resolver included. obsidian/workspace makes sense for me - but in your case it’s perfectly understandable. Sadly free options like syncthing is a lot faster in my experience. Syncthing is one of the "fire and forget" kind of programs. 🔗 Useful linksSyncthing has neither of those features. Now choose the option that says: “Create sync test”. I use Syncthing across 20+ machines, a lot of folders shared among several different people; we routinely hit terabytes of global state on some machines, Syncthing just handles it without a fuss. obsidian-releases - Community plugins list, theme list, and releases of Obsidian. For mobile devices, use Autosync or Foldersync, connect your cloud storage with this app, select your folder and sync (official clients don't work like a syncing service, just to download, upload and view your files basically). obsidian/workspace I sync more than just Obsidian but Obsidian vault folder is set for watch changes, sync on AC and battery, wifi and mobile data. Unless you changed some files before opening obsidian. 2. Select Let me create my own folder pair. What I managed to to is this: Select photos in the gallery app. 如只需閱. project: 🔀 syncthing integration merge ui: 🐛 date format in diff modal Features. Didn't have such problems, but yes, Resilio is more polished and stable. Platform: iOS Obsidian Mobile version 1. Obsidian sync and backup on Android: Autosync vs FolderSync? I am setting up a system to synchronize my Obsidian (which I use from Mac) with the mobile version for. Some people have been happy with iCloud but others have found it glitchy even. Obsidian Sync is a cloud-based service that lets you store your notes on Obsidian's servers and sync them across your devices. (PAID feature) by accessing other apps' sandboxes. It works excellently except for the fact that I would also like to make obsidian my journal/diary. As for benefiting/hurting the Syncthing brand, I do now see your concern. This is likely to create conflict files. Backup your Obsidian. Next, you need to set up local synchronization on your device. When comparing Trilium Notes and obsidian-git you can also consider the following projects: Joplin - Joplin - the secure note taking and to-do app with synchronisation capabilities for Windows, macOS, Linux, Android and iOS. On my pc, which I only rarely use, my Windows account is password protected too. This is likely to create conflict files. It doesn’t sync plugins currently. It syncs my mobile Obsidian Vault with my Syncthing Vault when I run it. (What I did. In the meta post there is someone going from iOS <> Androis <> Windows using iCloud and Syncthing but Linux would probably require going off of iCloud unless I can mount it locally (didn’t see any easy ways to do this online - I was able to mount a box drive locally in the. Syncthing is not designed to send and receive individual files, and for the purposes of this guide we will be using syncthing to sync entire game save folders that may or may contain multiple additional save files. Self-hosted LiveSync is a community-implemented synchronization plugin. Using this setup enabled me to have almost instant sync across all devices. Syncthing/Dropbox/Google Drive are all free options, I like syncthing best because I gave the vault on my NAS and connect via desktop, tablet and phone. 1. argentum2. So your data never hits their servers in an unencrypted form, so it's secure. Sync app does not need to run in the background all the time. I use markon to access and write in those files. Syncing Obsidian Files. Android: Resilio Sync Here, the Resilio Sync is used to mirror the Vault inside iCloud drive on the mac to the Android pohne. The obsidian Git plugin can be configured to automatically pull the most recent files when starting Obsidian. And the fact that Obsidian allows to have different enabled plugins on Mobile vs Desktop, made the decision. outright. I know you wrote this a long time ago, but I owe you a massive thank you as I was looking to the answer to this as a new Sync user. On Android, assuming Folder Sync didn’t have any errors, it was the same - a few seconds. The Discord has a number of users who seem fine with it and others who have given up on it. Open the Repository "Status and Configuration" settings. • 1 yr. Give a label and paste the folder path and don’t forget to remove the “double brackets”. The solution was to change in the Syncthing Android app the address of the NAS (external device) from default to the IP address, so for example tcp4://192. On Android, assuming Folder Sync didn’t have any errors, it was the same - a few seconds. assuming everything is set on your desktop obsidian including remotely syncing to onedrive. - If you already have Obsidian Sync enabled on a device, learn how to [[Set up Obsidian Sync on another device]]. The vault should point to the folder where NextCloud Client synchronises the Notes. Note that using multiple syncing services at the same time (e. I only work on one device at a time. ) I have a guide that shows you how to set up Syncthing to sync your Obsidian vault between devices for free. ¶. stignore files. Now, I pay for Obsidian Sync. bash sync. I have no need for version control on much else I do, so no intention of learning git. Obsidian 1. Some plugins will not work on mobile. Now you should see a screen that asks you to connect to a remote vault. ‘openssh’ is a suite of secure networking utilities based on the Secure Shell (SSH) protocol. Syncthing is even easier, and works very well. • Remotely Save plugin. Works reliably, never have issues and zero maintenance. That way your files are stored in the cloud too. md vault with git (by denolehov). 133 50. Thats it. Do you want to store files on a huge server -> use own/nextcloud. From there you pick a folder in the pc and sync that to your mobile. My approach is running syncthing at night sync all files to desktop and then run GitHub sync and sync everything to GitHub private repository. I’m already very familiar with Github, and I’m. All the above AND it’s interesting, promising, can be frustrating, fun to learn, seductive. 2. So for anyone who has been having the same frustrating experience with unusual conflicts that I was, your two options are: Disconnect your Android device and wait until 1. 133 50. 168. Features include: Has a built-in web browser, so you don't need to fire up an external browser. External edits will automatically get picked up. What’s the current state vs eventual goal? 2 Likes. For example, iCloud doesn’t work well with anything outside of Apple’s ecosystem, but currently no other cloud service works well with iPhones and iPads due to the restrictive file management on iOS. 27. Close the vault and reopen it. git pull. 3 Obsidian Desktop version: v0. 1 Like. Next, open "Autosync for Google Drive" and log into your Google Account. My experience is that it takes anywhere from 15 minutes. 10. Connect the app to your Google Drive’s account. End-to-End encryption is supported. 9. , you name it. Third Party Sync. A disadvantage of using GitHub to sync is that your files aren’t E2EE. Everything is working flawlessly, including sync from my desktop to 2 laptops and 2. Any time you make a change to a note, Obsidian encrypts your data, send it to any other devices with Sync set up, and it's de-encrypted on that device. However, Syncthing cannot sync with iOS devices because of that stupid sandboxing–or rather, because there’s… Self-hosted LiveSync plugin vrtmrz/obsidian-livesync GitHub - vrtmrz/obsidian-livesync Self-hosted LiveSync is a community-implemented synchronization plugin. Install it then enable it. Obsidian Sync gives you one year of version history for every note, so you can go back to see how the content changed. sh. md. How do I sync Desktop to iOS. Sync files between all your devices. There is real risk here so you better be sure you have a good handle on how OneDrive sync is going to work with your Obsidian devices. logseq - A local-first, non-linear, outliner notebook for organizing and sharing. The advantages of Obsidian Sync is that it’s officially supported, “just works,” has nice versioning that is built into Obsidian, and is blazing fast and optimized. Synctrayzor,Windows tray utility / filesystem watcher / launcher for Syncthing. The only time that it goes near a cloud is after it goes into a Cryptomator vault. Excellent program (9/10), app wrapper could use some polish (7/10), but all primary features are readily available with the advanced options accessible in the web setup (with a built-in link for access) But despite its small downfalls, it has a few astonishing surprises like disabling. I also now trust GitHub (Microsoft) less with my. Pretty frustrating as no other Syncthing folders/files have this issue, only the Obsidian vault folders/files. Syncing keeps your folder contents and file versions the same on all of your devices—if you make a change or add or delete a file or folder, the change or addition or deletion will happen. #obsidian #zettelkasten #syncToday's video covers setting up Obsidian Sync with a good encryption key and adding a synced vault to secondary devices. With the paid Sync service, it is rendered on my desktop machine in a second or two (after clicking on the three-dot icon to reveal the sync status, which may also “save” the file locally) With the SyncThing setup, it takes some 10 seconds or so to render the newly added text on the desktop machine (with syncing eventually handled by. Finally settled down with Obsidian as I can manage note files directly such as using Syncthing for backing up and syncing. →Syncthingなら、P2Pで複数の端末のローカルフォルダーを同期できる！ 導入する前に. I switched to Obsidian Sync eventually to support the developers, but if money is tight, I have no problem switching back. If Onedrive can automatically sync to all devices it can be used. It works seamlessly. veesarv. The easiest way to sync your notes between your devices is to use Obsidian Sync. But iTunes doesn't allow you to transfer folders directly, so you have to create the folders by yourself (mind that folder name should be EXACTLY the same, Caps and Spaces. so i have like 4 device (3 desktop and 1 smartphone). It’s a well-known problem fixed in Syncthing version 1. It looks great. There have been several solutions for. Apples and oranges. Obsidian Sync vs. Click the button on the right to turn it on and then click the gear icon to configure Sync. 95 7. Give your folder pair a name. It hosts and wraps Syncthing, making it behave more like a native Windows application and less like a command-line utility with a web browser interface. The Obsidian Forum has discussions about users using Notion and Obsidian or Obsidian and XYZ. The most important reason people chose Syncthing is:imsodin • 2 yr. My biggest fear is to lose the content of any note, if with obsidian sync I have the history of my md files, with free file sync just copy and paste my data. Right now, there are edge cases with sync no matter what system you use (Obsidian’s native Sync, Dropbox, GoogleDrive, iCloud, git etc). I have it synchronizing between two computers and my phone, but with my phone I have it excluding certain attachment folders to keep the space use down. This would be the best way to use it, but even if Syncthing isn't running simultaneously, as long as you start it & sync changes before making any new edits in Obsidian, it'll be fine. - If you want to know how to view or restore previous versions of a note, refer to [[Version history]]. folder. Available on every obsidian-compatible platform. poglet. That would probably be the best solution, but I have practical problems. I will explain the process step by step so that you can see your Obsidian vault on both your phone and computer. I’m using syncthing for quite some time to sync between Obsidian Desktop and Obsidian Mobile and it works fine. See also the local file sync tool FreeFileSync for handy local drive copying. Definitely obsidian sync is the way for you, you can control the files and folders that get synced. I've used SyncThing on a Windows box via WSL and so I know the Linux option can work. Do you want to syncronize files between several devices -> use syncthing. My current platforms: Linux desktop Ipad Android phone Linux NAS I. If we could afford it, we would use it. 1-200 users. Möbius Sync can sync files between multiple remote devices and multiple folders. Syncing means keeping your notes up to date across your devices, such as your laptop and phone. I am not sure if this is an issue with Syncthing or with Obsidian, but I'll post it here to know the mechanism of Obsidian I've set up syncthing between two PCs and two Android devices. If they all sync with onedrive then they each get the updates from syncthing and get the same updates again from OneDrive. Return to the SyncTrazor app and click on “Add folder”. git add . Möbius Sync is restricted. Or use rsync if you need to keep things in sync. The most straightforward option is to use Syncthing. This topic was automatically closed 7 days after the. ImportantIf you're using Obsidian Sync. A few weeks ago there were issues with Obsidian, but the latest release works again. Visual conflict resolver included. Hope that helps!Right now I'm just manually sync-ing it, and it's getting more annoying/time-consuming as time goes on. Uncheck Exclude hidden files. They actually just released a config syncing feature less than a week ago. I then just pointed Obsidian to create a new folder from the. Download the Dropbox App to your computer on which all your Obsidian files exist. I usually resolve these issues from my desktop or remove them from my vault folder when all devices are closed. Obsidian + Syncthing = Killer Combination. Although Syncthing does have a built in protection mechanism. It must be useful for the people who have limitations to using the cloud (e. Once you’re satisfied with the new vault, use Syncthing to sync it between your personal and work computers with a simple ignore pattern (on the personal computer side) to filter out everything except the path to your Obsidian settings (optional) and your work subfolder like so: !/. A few weeks ago there were issues with Obsidian, but the latest release works again. obsidian hidden folder so all of the plugins, themes, and css snippets will sync too. because I can also just sync the dotfolder of the Vault. More complex as well. Syncthing-Fork for Android, and SyncTrayzor on Windows. Remotely save always favor the most recent version of a file in case of conflicts. (Hết tháng 9/2021 này sẽ tăng giá, nên bạn có thể tranh thủ nếu thấy nó đáng. The latter costs $20 per month or $192 per year. 1 2,720 0. Syncthing vs rsync. 24 Share. I’m curious what benefits (besides cost) Obsidian Sync has over Obsidian Git and vice versa. 12. It is possible to use Git to sync an Obsidian vault between a mobile device and a computer without (1) resorting to a web-based hosting provider like Github as the middleman (should you want privacy), and (2) without worrying about setting up Git on the mobile device. Obsidian Sync gives you one year of version history for every note, so you can go back to see how the content changed. obsidian-omnisearch - A search engine that "just works" for Obsidian. If you can afford it, Obsidian Sync is well worth it for the privacy, versioning, granular control of what gets synced, and seamless syncing across any combination of. Here is a generic use-case w/ cloud sync: "Documents" Mac <-> "Documents" NAS -> "Documents" Google Drive "Uploads" Mac -> "Uploads" NAS -> "Downloads" Phone Is Synology Drive better at syncing local changes w/ NAS or is Syncthing better? Syncthing seems to offer more granular control, but Synology Drive. I’ve tried that but since I’m only able on iOS to either sync using Obsidian. (What I did. Open source, multi-user SDR receiver software with a web interface (by jketterl). Other apps, such as Foldersync, syncthing, or Drivesync, are needed for any of these services in order to make them functional on android. I have recently enabled syncing . People set up a a Home Server with Syncthing to have a Central location that is always on to Sync files using Syncthing whatever device it is. Synching is not the optimal way here. I can live with that. The former costs $10 per month or $96 per year. Author’s obsidian vault Fleeting Notes. SyncThing works with ANY files you want to sync to another device. It available for PC, Mac, Android and iOS (and should be Linux). There is no Files / 3rd-party cloud access. But when I customize something in my laptop like add a new plugin i need to repeat the work in android. Obsidian Mobile version: v1. I'd prefer this over Git for two reasons 1. I don't know if i should post this here or on r/Syncthing but I'll start here first. It is much faster and more convenient for me then other note taking apps. Combining this with syncthing seems to be the simplest solution if you like. every day I leave my work PC in the evening and then at home I run. Whilst I understand the importance of supporting great products, a few limiations of Obsidian Sync stand out to me:. Obsidian Git. Don't sync the . Then, paste in your NextCloud’s. It may work much better for you, in which case you won’t need Obsidian Sync. Stars - the number of stars that a project has on GitHub. I’ll usually have one obsidian file in every folder that contains pdfs and other file types. Browse for community plugins, and search: “Obsidian Git”. Bringing Syncthing to iOS. Here’s how I got my iPhone to sync with my existing vault that is stored on GitHub. Obsidian cannot directly read the repo in Working Copy afaik. This plugin allows you to synchronize your Obsidian vault with a remote device using Syncthing. Not sure why, I really liked what I saw. thanks , good to know that although not official, Dropbox works. When I first setup Syncthing, there was an instance where it deleted a file. ago. • 2 yr. Updated 14-Oct-2023. Get it here. SyncTrayzor is a little tray utility for Syncthing on Windows. )Hi, I'm using Obsidian on three devices. Source Code Source tar. First, open up Obsidian settings, select “Community Plugins,” and click on the gear icon next to “Remotely Save. The sequence of steps 1. I love how customizable and flexible Obsidian is. Recent commits have higher weight than older. Open Obsidian on your computer and go to Settings > Plugins. Joplin's native support of Nextcloud sync is really handy. Select Let me create my own folder pair. There has to be a file called ". But iTunes doesn't allow you to transfer folders directly, so you have to create the folders by yourself (mind that folder name should be EXACTLY the same, Caps and Spaces. UI explains why syncthing is running or not. EpiphanicSyncronica. Like, dozens and dozens of redundant "conflicted" changelog files over the course of a month, which I'm sure has something to do with the particular API triggers it uses. I will say, I paid for Obsidian Sync and it is worth it for me. If not, cool. Using Dropbox you can: 1) sync your vault with the cloud (and get the rollback facility as a bonus) and 2) store "zipped" files of your vault from time. Both BTSync (Resilio Sync) and Syncthing offer end-to-end encryption, ensuring data remains encrypted during transfer and storage. Nếu bạn dùng Android thì có thể dùng app FolderSync/DropSync/Syncthing để đồng bộ với Google Drive hoặc OneDrive. 00 / month and has limited storage and upload as well as limited upload size. 6 KB . Works perfectly. Give your folder pair a name. The process was amazingly seamless/painless. Bidirectional synchronization between devices nearly in real-time. It'll sync a system folder with a OneDrive folder, which OneDrive will then sync across your devices. Give the directory a specific name (Obsidian, maybe) and point it to the directory on your computer which contains your vault. Compare syncthing-android vs obsidian-git and see what are their differences. If you already have an Obsidian Sync subscription, see how to [[Set up Obsidian Sync]]. ago. I haven't used Obsidian Sync, hence I'm not sure how exactly it handles triggers for syncing process, but I would assume that it internally tracks the changes to notes within the vault. I found at least one post in here (How to sync Obsidian for free btw PC and iPhone/iPad - #14 by gertkeno) though of someone suggesting they got it to work using Möbius Sync. mobile But there is still conflicts for any Obsidian file I edit. Core Plugins. syncthing-android - Wrapper of syncthing for Android. Obsidian is after all my #1 favourite piece of software, and I use it all the time. The sync was instant and it's pretty secure. Syncthing Encryption and Security. Obsidian offer Obsidian Sync for $10/mo. 4. I use local sync using SyncThing (FOSS) using my home desktop external drive as the Obsidian 'mother host' data folders. •. [deleted] • 2 yr. But if you want to keep your Logseq graph synced across your devices right now, you need to use a third-party solution. If having your vault on your phone is useful to you, great. Security Question (Sync) Hi! Like many here, I'm trying to find a way to sync my mobile vault with my desktop vault. • 10 mo. Basically this did. FYI, I use syncthing to store my notes on my NAS. longform - A plugin for Obsidian that helps you write and edit novels, screenplays, and other long projects. Trying to use a remote repo on a remote server (local network, not Github) has been shown not to work properly and is not an advised setup, due to the fact that the repo will. Dropbox is designed as storage in the cloud, with the possibility of moving back (rollback) some versions. I liked Syncthing for my Linux Thinkpad and 2 Android devices. Obsidian Sync provides the convenience to sync between all. Now go to SyncTrazor and click on ‘add folder’. I exclude explicitly as such . As much as I love Nicole, and she deserves compensation, IMO that's too much. bobstro. Features. sh is located. And yes you need to ignore . You'd have to test it of course. Unless you have your workspace file checked in, this should be fine and not produce and merge conflicts. Signed up for Obsidian Sync and synced my Mac, Android phone and iPad. Cheesent Yes, configuration files are hidden files, on syncthing search for patterns to ignore image885×490 39. Yeah. Overall, it worked very well for me, since I work from home and spend 99% of my life connected to my home wifi. Could someone share the way you sync you vaults? Thanks lot!The official doc suggests that on iOS, Syncthing is not supported to sync one’s vault. Getting your vault synchronized is a two-step process: 1. I've set up Google Drive as the sync. If you’re on Windows 10, you may need to first click “Show more options” to see the full context menu. Absolutely not, IF you are already paying for a domain/self hosting other stuff. With Obsidian Sync, if I have made a lot of changes say, move a folder or rename a tag or two, I have to wait considerably longer for it to sync and then index before I can use it. 🔗 Useful links Syncthing has neither of those features. (To be clear, Obsidian is one of my. In comparison, if I set up Obsidian or Logseq using Syncthing I don't achieve such a robust syncing. Select a local folder where you want to store your Obsidian vault. Obsidian Sync costing $15/month is expensive for something that is easy to replicate for free (well, for me at least). Cross-platform apps. resilio has that selective sync feature where you have have say a 200gb folder on your desktop and then add that folder to your phone but the only thing that shows up is placeholder/shortcuts of the files, then you have to manually choose to download a file or folder. Let’s sync the obsidian folder now. select the show all files in windows explorer and then look for " . I do agree that the price of both sync and publish are to high. . Update – 31 August 2021 I have decided to subscribe to Obsidian Sync which is $5 per month (if billed monthly). My setup as a researcher. I use it along with git-sync [2] and syncthing [3] now I can sync the notes across my work, personal desktops and my.